Putting it into practice: deciding what is in, what is out, and making it stick
A school runs a training day on a new approach to teaching literacy. Staff leave enthusiastic. A year later, you walk through six classrooms and see six different things. Some teachers are using the new approach. Some are using what they used before. Some are doing a bit of both.
Nobody was lazy. Nobody was resistant. The school had good evidence and good intentions. What it did not have was a plan for putting the practice into place.
This is the last post in the series. Posts 4 and Post 5 asked you to audit what you do and to organise support in tiers. Both ask a school to change something. This post is about how.
Knowing what works is not enough
Evidence tells us what is likely to work. It does not tell us whether it will work in your school, with your staff and your students. That depends on implementation: how a practice is introduced, supported and kept going.
Change needs a deliberate and structured approach. Leaders are deliberate when they commit to a practice and plan for it. They are structured when they use reliable implementation components in a systematic way. AERO names four: working in stages, addressing enablers and barriers, choosing implementation strategies, and monitoring how implementation is going.
This post follows those four, with one step in front: deciding what is in and what is out.
Step 1: Decide what is in, and what is out
Every school collects strategies over time. Some were chosen on evidence. Some arrived with a program. Some were a good idea ten years ago. Before you add anything new, decide what is in and what is out.
This builds on Step 5 of the audit in Post 4: keep, add or change. Here it becomes a decision you write down.
AERO’s report gives examples of evidence-based practices most likely to improve learning for all students. They include explicit teaching, formative assessment, mastery learning, classroom management and family engagement. The report also describes a coherent technical core, where a system sets its non-negotiable positions on what the evidence shows works. Schools then adapt to their context while keeping to the core expectations.
A school can do the same. Be clear about what is core, what is flexible and what is out.
| Decision | What it means |
| In | Part of our core. Everyone teaches it the same way. We train for it and check it. |
| Flexible | Teachers choose how, within the principles of the core. |
| Not yet | Promising, but not now. We lack the need, the time or the training. We park it on purpose. |
| Out | We stop. It works against the evidence, our data shows it is not working, or it no longer earns its place. |
Four questions help you sort each strategy.
- Does it meet a need we can see in our data? Use the screening and progress data from Post 5.
- What does the evidence say? Use the levels in Post 4. The best evidence is the kind that fits your question.
- Does it fit with the rest of what we do? Does it follow the same principles as Tier 1: explicit, systematic, modelled and checked (Post 3)?
- Can we do it well? Think about time, training and people. A good strategy you cannot resource well is a “not yet”, not an “in”.
Two cautions.
First, “out” is about practices, not people. Most teachers teach the way they were trained to teach, as Post 4 said. Stopping a practice needs care and a plan, not blame.
Second, say no on purpose. Schools with other major projects running are less likely to finish them all well. Every yes, costs time and attention. Keep plans to a small number of clear, evidence-based goals.
Then write it down. A one-page list gives every teacher, new and experienced, the same picture.
| Strategy | Need it meets | What the evidence says | Fit and capacity | Decision: in, flexible, not yet or out |
Step 2: Work in stages
Rushing is a common mistake.
Be planned, be successful
| Stage | What to do | What to watch for |
| Explore | Choose one practice from your “in” list that meets an identified need. Decide whether to go ahead. | Choosing too many at once. |
| Prepare | Plan. Take a baseline. Build the team’s knowledge. Set up roles. | Changing classrooms before knowledge is in place.
Where is the teams knowledge at? Are they confident in the competence |
| Deliver | Put the practice into action. Check it is happening as planned and refine it. | How well are we delivering?
What are we seeing? |
| Sustain | Keep monitoring. Refresh knowledge. Share examples of what good looks like. | Assuming it is embedded because the training is over.
Checking in on our delivery and outcomes is an ongoing review. |
The stages are not a straight line. Teams can work in two at once, or go back.
Step 3: Check enablers and barriers before you start
Do not assume what will help and what will get in the way. Check.
| Enablers | Barriers |
| A stable implementation team. A clear plan. The principal making it a priority. Time release for coaches. A shared understanding of the practice. Practice experts inside the school. Learning from neighbouring schools. | Limited resourcing. Staff turnover and shortages. Secondary timetabling and assessment periods. Limited access to casual relief teachers in some areas. Gaps in practice expertise, which can lengthen the preparation stage. |
Then plan around what you find. If casual relief is hard to get, plan observation time differently. If turnover is high, write the practice down so it survives staff changes.
Step 4: Train in cycles, not one-off sessions
- One-off sessions rarely change practice across a school. Professional learning cycles, which combine knowledge-building, planning, modelling, communities of practice and coaching, work better.
- Build expertise inside the school. Work together, watch each other, develop a coaching environment where everyone is learning and developing togehter
- Resource it. Cycles are the most resource-intensive strategy. Time release for observation and coaching helps.
- Train the coaches. Train them in the practice and in coaching.
- Share the load. Give specific roles within the implementation and coaching teams.
Step 5: Lead it together
Senior leaders set the conditions. They provide the resources the change needs, whether that is time, knowledge or funding. They also protect the space where a new approach can take hold and grow.
But leadership does not stop at the top. Everyone leads when they take responsibility for the change and support each other through it. A teacher who shares what worked in her class is leading.
Shared leadership still needs clear roles. Make it clear who leads, who coaches and who checks.
Step 6: Check the doing, not just the results
Ask two questions, in this order. Is the practice happening as planned? Is it making a difference for students?
If you only look at results, you cannot tell whether a poor result means the practice does not work or that it was not delivered in the way it was intended. We need to monitor implementation as well as student outcomes, using structured review cycles.
- Student data: the screening and progress monitoring from Post 5.
- Implementation data: observation, coaching feedback, and whether practice looks as agreed in each year level.
A starting point for next term
- Sort your current literacy strategies into in, flexible, not yet and out.
- Choose one goal from your “in” list, linked to your data.
- Check enablers and barriers. Name a small implementation team.
- Plan a cycle: build knowledge, model, coach, review. Set time aside for it.
- Agree how you will check the practice is happening, and when you will review the data.
Small and deliberate beats big and rushed.
The series in one paragraph
Reading is built on language (Post 1). Early gaps tend to grow (Post 2). Strong teaching covers both strands of the rope (Post 3). Start with what you already do well (Post 4). Match support to need (Post 5). Then put it in place with a plan (Post 6).
Want support to put this into practice?
Peninsula Plus has coaches and professional learning to support schools on this journey. Give us a call at 03 5975 1500 OR email admin@penplus.com.au
Sources
- Australian Education Research Organisation (2026). Insights into implementation in schools in 2026. edresearch.edu.au
- Chng, A. and De Gioia, K. (2026). Implementing evidence-based practices in early childhood education and care, 2026. Australian Education Research Organisation.
- Lind, R., Davis, C. and Heenan, B. (2026). Leveraging evidence for system support. Australian Education Research Organisation. (Section on school-level recommendations read in part.)
- Education Endowment Foundation (2019). Four-stage implementation model, as adapted by AERO.
Check out our series
The Language House: Why Reading Starts Long Before Prep
The Matthew Effect in Reading: Why Early Reading Matters So Much
What to Teach in Literacy: The Key Elements and How to Teach Them
What is your school already doing well? A literacy audit
Multi-tiered Support: Keeping Literacy Support Targeted
Implementing literacy change in schools: deciding what is in and what is out

